It's Still Obvious - The Reynolds Report Feb 2021

Thoughts on the Supreme Court ruling in Financial Conduct Authority against Arch Insurance (UK) Limited and others [2021] UKSC1

Some of you may remember that, back in October (2020), I wrote an article about the decision of the Queen’s Bench Division Commercial Court in Financial Conduct Authority against Arch Insurance (UK) Limited and others [2020] EWHC 2448 (COMM). In this decision the Queen’s Bench Division, in a clear if somewhat lengthy judgment, required Arch Insurance (UK) and a raft of other insurers to pay out on various types of ‘business interruption’ policies with respect to the losses incurred by policyholders as a result of the COVID pandemic and/or the government’s response to that pandemic (see Reynolds report September 2020 ‘It’s obvious!’).

So how did the insurance companies respond to this decision?  Did they, promptly and with good grace, make the payments which the Queen’s Bench Division felt should be made?

Well, no. What they did was appeal the Court’s decision.

Given the extreme sensitivity of the issue, and no doubt aided by mellifluous argument from the ranks of Queen’s Counsel on display, permission to appeal (and to cross appeal and to intervene) was given and the matter was fast-tracked to the Supreme Court.  The judgement of the Supreme Court was produced on 15 January 2021.

The judgement of the Supreme Court, given by Lord Hambleden and Lord Leggatt (with Lord Reid in agreement) (and Lords Spriggs and Hodge concurring in result but differing in some of the reasoning), runs to some 90 densely worded pages in print.  It is complete with verbatim citations from ministerial speeches made over the relevant period and from the raft of regulations brought in to address COVID issues.

In the end, however, their Lordships upheld the decision of the lower court and dismissed the appeals of the insurance companies (although allowing in part cross appeals from the FCA and other interveners).  A range of standard policy clauses/policy types were upheld:

  1. Disease clauses – these provide insurance cover for business interruption loss caused by the occurrence of a notifiable disease at or within a specified distance of the policyholder’s business premises; and
  2. Prevention of access clauses – these provide cover for business interruption losses resulting from public authority intervention preventing or hindering access to or use of business premises

(There was also a third category – hybrid clauses – which combine the main elements of disease clauses and prevention of access clauses.)

Their Lordships also dealt with the issues of so-called ‘trends clauses’ and pre-trigger losses.

In this respect it was held that the Queen’s Bench Division had been wrong to find that the indemnity for business interruption loss sustained after cover was triggered, should be reduced to reflect a downturn in the turnover of the business due to COVID-19 generally (which, it was argued by the insurers, would have continued even if the cover had not been triggered by the insured peril).

Losses should be assessed on the assumption that there was no COVID-19 pandemic and, consistently with that conclusion, it should have been held that, in calculating loss, the assumption should be that pre-trigger losses caused by the pandemic would not have continued during the operation of the insured peril (i.e. prevention of access).

The rejection of proposed ‘trend clause’ adjustment – requiring losses to be adjusted on the basis that if the insured peril had not occurred the business would still have been affected by other consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic – was upheld in the Supreme Court.

It remains to be seen whether the insurers affected will now pay out with good grace – although it does seem they have little wriggle room left.  It may prove more problematic to repair their relationship with the numerous policyholders who feel, at the very least, aggrieved in this matter.

If you are having difficulty with your COVID business interruption claims Martin Reynolds and Justin Sadler of Barrett & Co and would be very happy to assist.  To book a virtual meeting with either of them please call our team on 0118 958 9711 or email on:  [email protected].

Further Reading:

The Reynolds Report September 2020 – It’s Obvious!

Reynolds Report December 2020 – “What a nuisance!”

The impacts of COVID19 on the property market

Monthly Legal News Update

Know your rights and keep up to date with changes to COVID-19 law – sign up for our monthly legal newsletter.

Enter your email address below to start receiving our monthly legal bulletin.

Get in Touch

Our Property and Commercial Department is headed by Martin Reynolds an experienced commercial solicitor with a background in commercial dispute resolution and insolvency law. To contact Martin and his team; call 0118 958 9711 or email [email protected].

"barrettandco" and "Barrett & Co" are trading names of Barrett & Co Solicitors LLP, a Limited Liability Partnership incorporated in England and Wales under registration number OC356263, with registered office at Salisbury House, 54 Queens Road, Reading, Berkshire RG1 4AZ. Barrett & Co Solicitors LLP is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority www.sra.org.uk (SRA Number 549694).

Disclaimer | Privacy Notice | Cookie Policy | Sitemap
© 2018 Barrett and Co. All rights reserved.

logo-footer

                

Search Barrett & Co

eg. wills, debt, property, divorce

Lockdown 2021

Business as usual in unusual times. We are continuing with all legal work during Lockdown 2021. We are still working hard on behalf of clients old and new. We are still conducting most meetings by telephone and/or via conferencing facilities. In particular we are pleased to continue to offer our fixed fee meetings of £95 inclusive of VAT for one hour, to enable clients to explore any new legal matter with which they are concerned.

We have reduced numbers of staff in our office as many employees are working from home where possible via email/video/telephone calls. (All data is secure.) Please do not come into our offices without an appointment. Thank you for your ongoing and loyal support and on behalf of everyone at Barrett and Co Solicitors we hope you remain safe and well. Please do email or call us for our virtual appointments on 0118 958 9711 or email [email protected] (or the direct email address of your Barrett & Co contact).